The film 'Being Heumann' tells the story of a group of disability rights activists fighting to be included in anti-discrimination legislation. The movie began streaming on Apple TV shortly after a brief theatrical release.
Who doesn’t love a good movie? Even better, is when it is watched with friends and fuels a great conversation. The staff at WindSwell got to do just that when we went to see Being Heumann last week (now available on Apple TV).
While the movie title is the same as Judy Heumann’s 2020 autobiography, the film’s plot centers around the 1977 25-day occupation of the San Francisco federal building. Featured is the story of the group of disability self-advocates who protested, as only those of the 70’s could do, that the added Section 504 of the1973 Rehabilitation Act had still not been codified.
The movie does a good job of capturing the anger of a diverse group of disabled young people throughout their nearly-monthlong occupation. Photos of the real-life events, shown at the end of the film reinforced the striking resemblances of the actors to those they portrayed, including their shared disability (as opposed to the actor imitating a disability they haven’t experienced). Access was the message, and we enjoyed being reminded that it is possible to wage a struggle with the highest level of government and WIN!
A movie like this one often features a staunch villain, and in Being Heumann, that role was filled by Joseph Califano, the Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare (HEW) in the Carter Administration. I was curious as to who he really was and why he was objecting to Section 504.
I learned that he is still alive at 95 years old and is praised for shaping welfare policies in the cabinets of two presidents. The Navy veteran has also earned the highest civilian honor from the Army, and he’s credited with helping ensure the passage of the Voting Rights Act while monitoring the progress of the civil rights March from Selma to Montgomery. He has mounted many health programs throughout his career, including the first national anti-smoking campaign. He has advocated for childhood immunizations, and he issued the first regulations providing opportunity to women under Title IX. This is not the resume of a villain, so why did he object initially to signing Section 504?
Califano eventually referred to his delay in signing 504 as “a learning experience.” He said he viewed disability rights positively, but he hadn’t considered disability as a “civil rights issue” and had stalled the process to review the implementation costs. Remember, at that time, those with disabilities were more likely to be institutionalized, or at best, less visible. Our communities were not accessible, so community integration was unlikely. Curb cuts were not commonplace. As we saw in the movie, ramps and access for all hospitals, federal buildings and schools were required to be provided within 60 days of the adoption of 504! Califano spoke candidly, and likely regretted saying, “We can’t help everybody!”
Section 504 – which protected qualified individuals from discrimination based on their disability – was a good start, but it would be another 13 years before the passage of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) implemented real systemic change.
President Carter, who had pledged to eliminate deficit spending by 1980, fired Califano in 1979. Ralph Nader at the time compared that action to “firing Mickey Mantle because he couldn’t get along with the bat boy.”
Things are different now, and yet; some things are still the same. Cost is too often the reason used for not doing the right thing. Some barriers remain. Lives that are not understood or experienced are easy for some people to marginalize.
But protests still work. Laws are in place and need to be protected. Being Heumann did a great job of reminding us all that we are more alike than different. There is power in numbers. Are we each the ally that we can be? Disability rights is civil rights!
“The way to right wrongs is to turn the light of truth upon them.” – Ida B. Wells
-Patti Hays previously wrote about lessons learned from Judy Heumann’s life shortly after the death of the disabilities rights icon in 2023. You can read that article through this link.-

WindSwell staff attended a showing of ‘Being Heumann’ during its brief theatrical release.
